Rum raisin ice cream (easy!)

Homemade rum raisin ice cream has real rum flavour you just can’t buy! This recipe uses a tried-and-proven method using whipped cream and condensed milk, no ice cream maker required. So easy it’s going to blow your mind!

Welcome back to the final instalment of Jamaican week! To recap, we started off with Jerk Fish, followed by two fabulous Jamaican sides – coconut rice and peas (beans, actually!) and Jamaican Slaw (adore!). And here today with dessert – rum raisin ice cream, the EASY way!!

Worth making: rum raisin ice cream

These days you can actually get quite good quality ice cream at the grocery store, though you do pay through the nose for it. But there are certain ice cream flavours that just don’t translate well when produced on a mass scale. Real fruit flavours, for one (like strawberry and mango).

And real rum flavour. Partially, I assume, because of regulations prohibiting the sale of real booze-laden food in regular grocery stores.

So if you’ve only ever had store bought rum raisin ice cream, the flavour in this homemade one is going to knock your socks off. I especially love the little chewy pops of rum soaked raisins!

Close up of scoop of Rum raisin ice cream

About the no-churn ice cream method

This ice cream recipe uses a miracle no-ice-cream-maker method that’s been around for decades! It uses fluffy whipped cream which replicates the effect of incorporating air into traditional ice cream by churning in an ice cream maker. Meanwhile, the condensed milk adds sweetness as well as preventing the mixture from freezing into a block of ice.

The outcome? An ice cream that’s scoop-able and creamy, just like real ice cream! Skeptical? Don’t blame you. Read glowing reviews here and here!

Condensed milk for Rum raisin ice cream — Condensed milk is used in miracle no-churn ice cream

Bowl of freshly whipped Chantilly cream - French whipped cream — Condensed milk is used in miracle no-churn ice cream

What’s the difference to using an ice cream maker? The melted ice cream is a bit richer (creamier) because no-churn ice cream is made using cream as the base whereas traditional ice cream is made with milk and egg. Hardly a “negative”! You can see the drips on the ice cream at the top of the post are thicker than traditional ice cream.

Sprinkling chocolate o Rum raisin ice cream — I like to sprinkle my rum raisin ice cream with chopped rum raisin chocolate.

Ingredients in rum raisin ice cream

Here’s what you need to make this incredible rum raisin ice cream:

Cream – Just ordinary whipping cream. I use thickened cream (heavy cream) but any whipping cream works fine. (Low fat cream is not an option here, recipe won’t work).

The aeration in the whipped cream replicates the effect of churning with an ice cream maker which is called for with traditional ice cream recipes.
Condensed milk – Sweetened milk sold in cans which has a syrupy consistency. Find it in the long-life milk aisle. This adds sweetness into the ice cream and prevents the mixture from freezing into a block of ice, keeping the mixture scoop able like real ice cream!
Rum – Use a golden or dark (brown) rum, for colour and flavour. Not a clear/white rum like Bacardi. I use Appleton Estate (pictured above) which is a good Jamaican made rum brand available here in Australia. But any rum will work here, even an economical one (we’re not doing shots here, it’s mixed with other flavours, so it’s ok!).
Raisins – Did the recipe name give it away? 😂 Sultanas make a fine substitute. Other dried fruit, like cranberries, cherries, even chopped dates, will work fine too as an alternative.
Allspice – For a hint of extra flavour. I tried it with and without (I know, my job, it’s so hard….) and just a bit of spicing makes it even better! But, it is optional.
Vanilla – For flavour.

Soaking rum for Rum raisin ice cream — If you chop the raisins and heat the rum, the raisins will absorb the rum faster. If you use whole raisins and cold rum, it’s best to leave overnight.

How to make rum raisin ice cream

Ahh, the magic of this no-churn ice cream method!!! Ready to see how easy it is? Or do you already know because you discovered my no-churn Strawberry ice cream or Mango ice cream??

Soak raisins – Soaking raisins in rum is key not only for great rum flavour but also because the rum stops the raisins from freezing into mini ice cubes.

Give the raisins a rough chop. This helps them absorb the rum more easily. Break them up with your fingers (they are often packed together tightly in the bags) then soak in hot rum for 30 minutes.

The raisins should absorb most of the rum. If there’s any residual liquid, pour it off. You want to limit the total liquid rum in the ice cream mixture to 1/4 cup (60 ml) total. Any more than this and the ice cream won’t set enough because rum doesn’t freeze due to the high alcohol content. Yes, I did trial and error to figure out the maximum amount of rum I could get into the ice cream!!
Condensed milk & flavours – Beat together the condensed milk, vanilla and allspice powder, just to combine. You don’t actually need a beater for this step, I just do because I’ve got the beater out anyway. Just give it a quick wipe before whipping the cream.
Stir in raisins – Add the rum soaked raisins and stir to mix through.
Whip cream until it is well whipped. It will take about 2 1/2 to 3 minutes with a handheld beater, or 1 to 1 1/2 minutes on high with a stand mixer. We are not looking for elegant softly whipped cream here. We want good aeration! (But not butter, which is what you’ll end up with at about the 8 minute mark, so stop before then! 😂)

Lighten condensed milk – Add a big scoop of whipped cream into the condensed milk mixture then fold through with a rubber spatula or big scooping spoon. The purpose of this step is to lighten up the condensed milk mixture before mixing it all into the cream to maintain as much aeration in the cream as we can. More aeration = creamier ice cream!

Just gently mix the cream through until it is mostly incorporated. Some lumps is fine.
Mix with cream – Pour the condensed milk mixture into the cream them fold to combine until it is cream-lump-free.

Be gentle here, don’t mix vigorously, as we want to preserve as much of the aeration in the cream as we can. To help remove cream lumps, “smear” visible cream bits across the surface or against the side of the bowl rather than vigorously stirring.

Pouring Rum raisin ice cream into ice cream container

Pour the mixture into a glass or ceramic container that is at least 1.5 litres / 1.5 quarts. I use a 1.75 litre / 1.75 quart glass loaf pan (28 x 15 x 7.5cm / 11 x 6 x 3″).

Smooth the surface, pop a lid on or cover with cling wrap.
Freeze for 12 hours. Then scoop and serve like normal ice cream!

You can basically scoop it straight out of the freezer, you don’t need to leave it out even for a minute before scooping. This is the rum at work – alcohol doesn’t freeze solid. So, as noted above, actually my biggest “challenge” in this recipe was figuring out how I can max out rum flavour without the ice cream ending up like a slushy! (The answer is reflected in the recipe 😂)

Serve in cones or in bowls, as many or as little scoops as you like.

The ice cream will keep in the freezer for months, just like “real” ice cream. It does freeze a little firmer from day 3 and beyond, it only requires a few minutes on the counter before scooping.

Lastly, just a note on the booziness of this ice cream! Even though the amount of rum per serving is not that much (3/4 cup in total), let’s keep this one away from kids and pooches. Ordinarily my recipes that use alcohol will cook the alcohol out so it’s negligible in the finished dish. But in rum raisin ice cream, it is not. And that’s just how we grown ups love it! – Nagi x

Watch how to make it

Hungry for more? Subscribe to my newsletter and follow along on Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram for all of the latest updates.

food 4u